As I predicted

2nd March 2019 Off By binary
start trading binary options



This morning I read a post by noted MMTer Stephanie Kelton, which responded to some questions by Paul Krugman. I predicted that he’d be pulling out his hair, as her responses were a complete mess—as if she didn’t understand the simple questions he was asking. Here’s an excerpt from my Econlog post:

I can’t even imagine Krugman’s reaction to all this.  First of all, although she says “no” in answer to question #1, her explanation makes it quite clear that she is actually answering “yes”, especially when you combine the answers to questions #1 and #2.  Krugman is asking whether, assuming a given macroeconomic situation (including a given level of private spending), there is only one budget deficit consistent with full employment.  She clearly thinks the answer is yes.  So why does she answer “no”.  I suspect she doesn’t understand Krugman’s question (which is pretty straightforward.)

Now Krugman has responded and he’s every bit as frustrated as I expected. Here is his response to the first point I raised:

Her response to my first question totally misses the point; I was asking if *given private behavior* there’s a unique level of the deficit needed for full employment, and argued that there wasn’t. She just assumes that there is

And here’s how Krugman summarizes his twitter thread:

Sorry, but this is just a mess. Kelton’s response misrepresents standard macroeconomics, my own views, the effects of interest rates, and the process of money creation. Otherwise I guess it’s all fine. See what I mean about Calvinball? 6/

MMT desperately needs a spokesperson capable of conversing with economists like Paul Krugman, if they want to be taken seriously. When they give bizarre answers to serious questions from a highly respected economist on their side of the ideological spectrum, it’s a problem.

Not surprisingly, I think it’s perfectly fine to be heterodox, but first you need to understand orthodox.




Read more about eu binary options trading and CFD brokers